According to experts, $ 1,000 baby bonus professionals and opposition in ‘Trump Accounts’

chairman Donald TrumpProposal for a new Savings account Just found one sign stamp of approval,

This week in the “Investment America” ​​roundate in the White House, several top CEOs, including Michael del And Goldman Sachs Chief David Solomon expressed support “Trump accounts,” which are part of the landmark Republican-supported “Big Beautiful Bill”, which run through the Congress. The authorities committed to contribute to the accounts of their employees’ children, and in the case of Dale, the government’s seed money matches the “dollar for dollars”.

Nevertheless, policy experts and financial advisors question whether the provision is the most effective way to save from your child.

Below Remedy of homeTrump Accounts – First known as “Money Accounts for Growth and Advancement” or “Maga Accounts” – can later be used for education expenses or credentials, first as home or capital to start a small business. Earnings are taxed, and qualified withdrawal is taxed at a long-term capital-profit rate.

More than personal finance:
Trump’s ‘Big Beautiful’ bill can curb low -income tax credit
What is ‘Revenge Tax’ for investors in Trump’s Bill
What is happening to unemployed Americans – in 5 charts

Trump’s mass tax and expenditure bills still face a fight in the Senate, but if it passes as a draft, the parents and others will be able to contribute to a child’s Trump account to $ 5,000 per year. The remaining amount will be invested in a diverse fund that tracks the US-stock index.

Sen Ted Cruise, R-Texas, who led the attempt, told CNBC in May that accounts give children “the ability to deposit money, which is transformative.”

The White House also said, “It will give a chance of children a chance to experience a miracle of mixed development and set them on a course for prosperity from the beginning.” statement monday.

Some experts say that the biggest advantage of Trump accounts is seed money for all children born between January 1, 2025 and 1 January 2029, Treasury department,

There are no income requirements. To be eligible, the child must be an American citizen and both parents must have social security numbers.

Although some states, including connecticut and colorado, already offer a kind of type “”Baby bond“Program for parents, trump accounts – with a large child tax credit Proposed in budget bills and potential employer-proposed matching funds-“Surely a lot of families can help a lot of different income levels,” Sam Tub, Nerdwellist’s leading investment writers, Recently told CNBC,

Invested in a comprehensive equity index fund for 20 years, a government grant of $ 1,000 for newborns could increase to an average of $ 8,000, according to which 1 March report From Milken Institute. Researchers wrote, “If the policy also allows the tax-cutable match by the parents of the children’s parents, such initial matches would double the account value,” the researchers wrote.

With Trump accounts, “costs are important,” he said: “If it keeps adding to the deficit, it is not durable.” (By some accounts, the program may cost more than the program $ 3 billion per year,

“The biggest challenge for this country is that we have lived beyond our means,” he said. “In the last 230 years, the Congress has passed such countless programs, providing short -term benefits that are almost always dwarf by long -term costs.”

Universal savings accountWhich allows for more flexibility, would be a better proposal than the provision of the house, a public policy think tank, Director of Tax Policy Studies at the Cato Institute, Adam Mitchell said.

Universal savings accounts are going back as bipartisan supports Clinton AdministrationAnd without initial deposits, very low cost will come. They have also been successfully implemented in other countries, including Canada And this United kingdomAccording to the Tax Foundation.

In addition, Trump accounts are “highly restricted and unnecessarily complex,” Mitchell said. “A simple system is a better way to save people.”

With a universal savings account, individuals can contribute up to $ 10,000 after tax income in a year and Take back tax-free money For any purpose at any time, according to Mitchell.

“This is flexibility that entice people,” he said. “Maybe you want to use that money to start or expand a business or buy home or investment property – let people choose what is the best for their life.”

Another option is an exploitation 529 College Savings SchemeWhich provides almost every state.

These 529 schemes have a lot of contribution limitations, earnings grow on a tax-up basis, and when a child withdraws money, it is tax-free if money is used. Qualified education expenditureThis year, individuals can give a gift of up to $ 19,000 up to 529, or up to $ 38,000. If you are married and enter taxes jointly, without those contributions per child are counting the gifts of your lifetime without those contributions.

Although 529 funds can be implemented compared to Trump accounts, there are more limitations on it, restrictions to include continuous education classes in recent years are loose, Apprenticeship program And Student loan payment,

“For most parents, like a teen with themselves, 529 college savings scheme is better if you focus on paying for higher education due to federal tax-free development,” Winnie SunIrwin, co-founder and managing director of Sun Group Wealth Partners located in California, recently reported to CNBC.

“, Now, now, 529 getting more flexible with its’ unused money capacity, a Roth rolled into Ira for future retirement,” Sun said, “said,” said, “said. CNBC Financial Advisory Council,

By 2024Families can roll 529 funds inappropriate for account beneficiaries Roth personal retirement accountWithout triggering income tax or punishment, so they meet some requirements until they meet.

Subscribe to CNBC on YouTube.